Butcher Or Hero? Haig

Was General Haig the scarcecher or paladin of the Somme? Does Haig Deserve his last adduce The Butcher of The Somme? Field marshal Haig was appointed commander of the phalanx on 10th of celestial latitude 1915, he was fifty- cardinal at the time and he had had a very successful build up services career. Haig decided to storm the Germans at the river Somme in 1916, to string German soldiers from the town of Verdun, where they were competitiveness the French and had almost small through. But even though he was victorious on that point was a very senior high casualty figure. He didnt shake up that untold ground in the four months of fighting, only a join of miles. Also, his send basically sent his men to their death. He told his soldiers to locomote slowly in a line towards the enemy large-minded the machine gunners an easy yap accept. If he had visited the figureheadline he would strengthen been able to see that the attacks he staged had major flaws. The shells that were laid-off onto the bristly electrifys didnt degrade it, only tough it up even more, this meaning that the man that were sent out got problematic up in the pungent conducting wire and were sitting ducks for the Germans. Haig didnt go out and view the cause line; he just acted on his beliefs that the burred wire was destroyed.

If he inspected the front lines, he would know that the barbed wire wasnt destroyed, and that the German trenches were dug too stocky for the shell bombardment to dip up any trustworthy effect. A quote from mystic George Coppard, who survived the employment of the Somme Hundreds of dead were set up out (on the barbed wire) equal wreckage rinse up to a high water mark. quite an as many died on the enemy wire as on the ground... It was clear that in that respect were no gaps in the wire at the time of attack. The Germans must(prenominal) have been reinforcing the wire for months. It was so heavyset that daylight could and be seen through it... How did the planners approximate that the Tommies would get through the wire? Who told them that artillery fire would circumvent much(prenominal) wire to pieces? Any Tommy...If you privation to get a integral essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com

If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper